Welcome to the League of Alternative Reality (LABR) FAAB report, on its new home at creativesports 2.0. I’ll be dropping by every Monday, sharing the results of Sunday night’s FAAB run, with commentary from American League competitor Lawr Michaels, National League site representative Brian Walton and yours truly, battling in the Mixed Draft League.
The American League only and National League only formats are 12-team contests using standard 5×5 scoring rules. There’s an old-school flavor as players purchased in the auction cannot be freely bounced from the active to reserve roster. A player purchased in the auction can be placed on the disabled list if he’s on the MLB DL. However, he can’t be reserved then replaced by a player won with FAAB; he must be released. A auction-purchased player may also moved to reserves if subsequently sent down to the minors.
The 15-team Mixed LABR league allows free movement between active and six-man reserve.
In all three leagues, a player acquired via FAAB must be immediately inserted into the team’s active lineup.
Each LABR squad starts with 100 FAAB units, with a minimum bid of $1. Owners can ask for a FAAB rebate upon releasing a player on the DL.
Each week’s report will display the winning bids along with listing all contingency and failed bids so you get a feel for the level of interest in each player.
After the tables showing the successful and unsuccessful bids, Lawr, Brian and I will offer some commentary for our respective leagues. I’ll share additional thoughts for each league.
The heading for each league doubles as a publicly accessible link so you can check the standings, roster and complete list of transactions.
SUCCESSFUL BIDS
PLAYER | WINNING BID | |||
Tyler Austin, NYY | Rotowire 13 | Creative Sports 8 | USA TODAY Sports 5 | Baseball Prospectus 5 |
Fangraphs 1 | ||||
Drew Butera, KC | Creative Sports 6 | Baseball Prospectus 3 | ||
Kevin Jepsen, TEX | SiriusXM 3 | Winning Fantasy Baseball 1 | ||
Tyler Naquin, CLE | Fangraphs 2 | Creative Sports 5 | NFBC 1 | |
Doug Fister, TEX | Creative Sports 2 | SiriusXM 3 | ||
Jake Smolinski, OAK | Creative Sports 2 | |||
Ichiro Suzuki, SEA | Fangraphs 2 | Rotowire 2 | ||
Ryan Tepera, TOR | Winning Fantasy Baseball 1 | Fangraphs 1 | ||
Rob Refsnyder, TB | Fangraphs 1 | Creative Sports 1 | ||
Carlos Tocci, TEX | Rotowire 1 | Creative Sports 1 | ||
Brian Johnson, BOS | Colton & The Wolfman 1 | |||
Justin Grimm, KC | Fangraphs 1 |
UNAWARDED BIDS
PLAYER | ||||
Ryan Buchter, OAK | Fangraphs 1 | SiriusXM 1 | ||
Jesus Sucre, TB | ESPN.com 1 | |||
Mike Marjama, SEA | ESPN.com 1 | |||
Sandy Leon, BOS | ESPN.com 1 | |||
Chris Young, LAA | Fangraphs 1 | |||
Daniel Robertson, TB | Fangraphs 1 | |||
Drew Robinson, TEX | Fangraphs 1 | |||
Danny Barnes, TOR | SiriusXM 1 | |||
Joe Kelly, BOS | SiriusXM 1 | |||
Sergio Romo, TB | SiriusXM 1 | |||
Zach McAllister, CLE | SiriusXM 1 |
Lawr Michaels’ Commentary
As the AL LABRites teams play standings leapfrog over the first weeks of the season, half the dozen league owners made FAAB lineup tweaks while six owners determined no free agent help was appropriate this cycle.
Topping the financial festivities was Yankees first sacker for now, Tyler Austin, who went to Jeff Erickson (RotoWire) for $13, besting four bids ranging from $1-5. Jeff also made a sneaky smart pick up with Carlos Tocci, of the Rangers, a speedy Rule 5 selection who logically will stick with the roster for all of 2018.
Oddly, my purchase of Drew Butera ($6) was the second highest expenditure, and though Butera is both older, and not the stick of the injured Salvador Perez, but, he should get some at-bats as I stream backstops (Butera replaced the injured Josh Phegley for now). I also grabbed a couple of fliers in Doug Fister ($2) and Jake Smolinski ($2) whom Oakland would really like to be their everyday centerfielder.
Ray Flowers tried to buoy his squad, adding Kevin Jepsen for a buck, while Eno Sarris bagged a cluster of cheap games, starting with Ichiro Suzuki ($2), Tyler Naquin ($2), Justin Grimm ($1), and Rob Refsnyder ($1), making the Fangraphs team the most active of the week.
Finishing off the bottom bid feeders, Glenn Colton and Rick Wolf took a chance on Brian Johnson, and Larry Schechter dropped a similar winning dollar to land Toronto hurler Ryan Tepera.
Todd’s Take
I’ll side with Team Dustin Fowler for the Athletics’ eventual center fielder, though Smolinski always finds his way into the lineup.
Starting pitchers were down on the wish list of the combatants this week, but if there’s still time, check out Brian Johnson, who draws a Miami Marlins squad in the Aquarium, aka Marlins Park. The Fish did some work against the Cubs over the weekend, but they’re still a below average lineup.
SUCCESSFUL BIDS
PLAYER | WINNING BID | |||
Ryan Flaherty, ATL | Lenny Melnick 6 | Rotowire 5 | USA TODAY Sports 2 | Derek Carty 1 |
Garrett Cooper, MIA | Rotowire 3 | |||
Tommy La Stella, CHC | USA TODAY Sports 2 | Rotowire 1 | ||
Tony Wolters, COL | Baseball HQ 1 | |||
Chad Wallach, MIA | Baseball Prospectus 1 | |||
Brandon Kintzler, WSH | CreativeSports 1 | |||
Deven Marrero, ARI | Rotowire 1 |
UNAWARDED BIDS
PLAYER | ||||
Caleb Smith, MIA | Lenny Melnick 5 | |||
Eddie Butler, CHC | Lenny Melnick 5 | |||
Edubray Ramos, PHI | Lenny Melnick 4 | |||
Chris Stewart, ATL | Baseball Prospectus 1 | Baseball HQ 1 | ||
Pat Valaika, COL | Lenny Melnick 1 | Rotowire 1 | ||
A.J. Ellis, SD | Baseball HQ 1 | |||
Jared Hughes, CIN | CreativeSports 1 | |||
Jose Ramirez, ATL | CreativeSports 1 | |||
Charlie Culberson, ATL | Lenny Melnick 1 | |||
Justin Wilson, CHC | Lenny Melnick 1 | |||
Braxton Lee, MIA | Rotowire 1 | |||
Christian Villanueva, SD | Rotowire 1 | |||
Greg Garcia, STL | Rotowire 1 | |||
Kyle Farmer, LAD | Rotowire 1 | |||
Phil Gosselin, CIN | Rotowire 1 | |||
Yadiel Rivera, MIA | Rotowire 1 |
Brian Walton’s Commentary
In the second waiver period of 2018 in National League LABR, three free agents were acquired for greater than the $1 minimum.
Leading the way is first-series phenom Ryan Flaherty of the Braves. Unfortunately for his $6, new owner Lenny Melnick will not receive any of the second baseman’s 7-for-13 start to the season. There is nothing in the pedigree of the 31-year old long-time Orioles reserve – who has a career batting average of .219 – to suggest that .571 is anything other than a blip on the radar. Still, with little to choose from on the waiver wire, bidding was spirited, with Melnick needed every dollar to get his man.
Quietly, Garrett Cooper had a nice, though brief introduction with the Yankees last season and the first baseman-outfielder should receive decent reserve at-bats for the Marlins in 2018. The 27-year old went to Jeff Erickson of RotoWire on an uncontested $3 bid. In hindsight, I should have grabbed Cooper last week over his teammate Tomas Telis, who I had hoped would become catcher-eligible in J.T. Realmuto’s absence. Chad Wallach and Bryan Holaday screwed up that plan, or should I blame Don Mattingly? Or Derek Jeter? Or myself?
If it seems like Tommy LaStella has been around for a while now, the feeling is warranted. The infield reserve is entering his fourth partial year as a member of the Cubs. Despite a career .265 average, the 29-year old has never received more than 148 at-bats in a season with Chicago. The left-handed hitter went 2-for-4, including a double in the first series and joined the roster of Steve Gardner of USA TODAY Sports for an uncontested $2.
I needed a pitcher to replace last week’s waiver wire addition of Miami’s Elieser Hernandez, who has yet to make his first start after requiring emergency dental surgery just before Opening Day. That has to be a first! After drawing zeros this week, he became my sixth player on the DL in this young season. Rather than chase more marginal starters, I grabbed dependable reliever Brandon Kintzler of Washington for a buck.
In terms of early FAAB management strategy, Melnick at $84 remaining is among three owners with $90 or less remaining. At the other end of the spectrum, three owners have yet to make a move through two weeks, holding their full $100 stipend. Either it was very fortunate drafting a month early or it is a higher priority for the trio to conserve cash for a mid-season roster boost after a big trade into the NL.
Todd’s Take
i remain intrigued by Garrett Cooper. Hitting has never been his roadblock; finding an open defensive spot is. Though, since his glove is best suited for either of the corner infield or outfield spots, his thump isn’t enough to force a team’s hand. Still, the Marlins may as well see if there’s anything there, making Cooper a nice option in deep leagues. He’ll pick up OF eligibility soon enough and could even gain legality at the hot corner down the line.
SUCCESSFUL BIDS
PLAYER | WINNING BID | |||
Hunter Strickland, SF | Baseball Prospectus 24 | RotoExperts/ FNTSY 24 | Yahoo Sports 22 | Fred Zinkie 21 |
@TheFantasyFix 18 | Prospect 361 17 | Fangraphs – Sleeper & Bust 16 | ||
Fangraphs 14 | Rotowire 11 | Scout Fantasy 6 | ||
Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 6 | ||||
Jordan Zimmermann, DET | @TheFantasyFix 18 | RotoExperts/ FNTSY 1 | Yahoo Sports 1 | Baseball Prospectus 1 |
Fred Zinkie 1 | ||||
Ty Blach, SF | ESPN.com 9 | Fred Zinkie 1 | ||
Nick Markakis, ATL | ESPN.com 5 | USA TODAY Sports 4 | Rotowire 1 | |
Keynan Middleton, LAA | Fangraphs 5 | Yahoo Sports 5 | @TheFantasyFix 3 | RotoExperts/ FNTSY 2 |
Fred Zinkie 1 | ||||
Dixon Machado, DET | Prospect 361 4 | |||
Jake Marisnick, HOU | USA TODAY Sports 4 | |||
Yan Gomes, CLE | Fangraphs 3 | @TheFantasyFix 1 | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 1 | Yahoo Sports 1 |
Francisco Cervelli, PIT | Yahoo Sports 3 | Baseball HQ 2 | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 2 | @TheFantasyFix 1 |
Fangraphs 1 | ||||
Ian Kennedy, KC | @TheFantasyFix 3 | |||
Jaime Garcia, TOR | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 2 | |||
Joe Panik, SF | RotoExperts/ FNTSY 2 | Fred Zinkie 1 | Rotowire 1 | |
Jed Lowrie, OAK | Fred Zinkie 1 | USA TODAY Sports 1 | Rotowire 1 | |
Darren O’Day, BAL | Fred Zinkie 1 | @TheFantasyFix 3 | ||
Matt Shoemaker, LAA | Fred Zinkie 1 | Fangraphs 1 | Baseball Prospectus 1 | |
Colby Rasmus, BAL | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 1 | |||
Kevin Plawecki, NYM | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 1 | Baseball HQ 1 | Yahoo Sports 1 | |
Aledmys Diaz, TOR | Rotowire 1 | Fred Zinkie 1 | ||
Matt Moore, TEX | Baseball Prospectus 1 | |||
Roberto Perez, CLE | @TheFantasyFix 1 | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 1 |
UNAWARDED BIDS
PLAYER | ||||
Tyler Austin, NYY | @TheFantasyFix 17 | Rotowire 1 | ||
Clayton Richard, SD | @TheFantasyFix 3 | Baseball Prospectus 1 | ||
Kevin Jepsen, TEX | @TheFantasyFix 3 | |||
Robert Gsellman, NYM | @TheFantasyFix 3 | |||
Howie Kendrick, WSH | USA TODAY Sports 2 | Rotowire 1 | ||
Matt Duffy, TB | USA TODAY Sports 2 | Rotowire 1 | ||
Matthew Boyd, DET | @TheFantasyFix 2 | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 1 | ||
Denard Span, TB | USA TODAY Sports 2 | |||
Collin McHugh, HOU | @TheFantasyFix 2 | |||
Jose Urena, MIA | @TheFantasyFix 2 | |||
Andrew Knapp, PHI | Yahoo Sports 1 | Razzball (Rudy Gamble) 1 | Fangraphs 1 | |
Caleb Joseph, BAL | Yahoo Sports 1 | |||
Chad Wallach, MIA | Yahoo Sports 1 | |||
Chris Stewart, ATL | Yahoo Sports 1 | |||
Drew Butera, KC | Yahoo Sports 1 | |||
Max Stassi, HOU | Yahoo Sports 1 | |||
Brian Johnson, BOS | Fred Zinkie 1 | |||
Kendall Graveman, OAK | Fred Zinkie 1 | |||
Marco Gonzales, SEA | Fred Zinkie 1 | |||
Ryan Flaherty, ATL | Fred Zinkie 1 | |||
Tyler Wade, NYY | Fred Zinkie 1 | |||
Will Harris, HOU | Fred Zinkie 1 | |||
Yusmeiro Petit, OAK | Fred Zinkie 1 |
Todd Zola’s Commentary
Hunter Strickland was the giant catch this week, and for good reason. Despite being passed over in the past when San Fran needed a closer, they appear to be ready to hand them the ball in Mark Melancon’s absence. The skills are there, he just needs to display some consistency. The Giants hope Melancon returns soon, but I see some Huston Street here, expecting injuries to be a frequent occurrence in between stretched of marginal success.
Kenyan Middleton was also picked up for saves, and he might be the Angles ninth inning answer. But, remember, the question is being asked to Mike Scioscia so the answer is usually multiple choice, with Cam Bedrosian, Jim Johnson and incumbent Blake Parker in the mix as well. I’m not giving up on Parker. He has the best skills and one poor outing early shouldn’t cost his job.
Todd’s Take
It was a quiet week for me. As opposed to last season, I’ve avoided early injuries, even with a February draft. I know this won’t last, but I still didn’t see anyone available good enough to upgrade my reserves. it helps three flyers I took landed jobs (Tyler Mahle, Neil Walker and Greg Holland).